Some critics, for example, question the very idea of having or owning property when talking about intellectual property. In debates over intellectual property, as in debates over freedom of expression, healthcare, global trade, even democracy itself, political theory can be of help, because it draws our attention to the differences, as well as the similarities, between peoples interests, and reminds us that conflict, as well as cooperation, can be morally justified. Review of intellectual property and theories of justice by madhavi. In a free enterprise economy, inventive activity is supported by using the invention to create property.
The goal of this chapter is not to develop a theory about the differences between the various. Download this book intellectual property and theories of. Free property law books download ebooks online textbooks. This essay canvasses those theories, evaluates them, and considers the roles they do and ought to play in lawmaking. The liaisons between intellectual property and social justice are uneasy. Ip rights surely have an effect on distributive justice, but these rights are defensible nonetheless. Rawlss major contribution to the theory of social justice. The center for science and justice, led by professor brandon garrett, will apply legal and scientific research to reforming the criminal justice system. Fourteen philosophers, economists and legal scholars address the question can intellectual property rights be fair. While never quite distinguishing between a philosophy, an approach, and a theory of intellectual property, fisher identifies four analytical constructs, which we will call theories, namelyi utilitarian for maximizing net social value, ii lockean one has the right to the fruits of his intellectual labour.
Justificatory theories for intellectual property viewed. In finding out the alternate forms of protection, papadopoulou finds that property, rights, liabilities, and rewards are forms of protection that conform to the objectives of justice and fairness, as the idea of justice formulated by rawls. The importance of intellectual property in india is well established at all levels statutory, administrative and judicial. India ratified the agreement establishing the world trade organisation wto. Intellectual property and theories of justice springerlink. A comprehensive introduction to the principal theories of trademark law and unfair competition, law. Lockes theory of property is one of the more influential readily avail able accounts. Review of intellectual property and theories of justice, co erasmus. William fisher, theories of intellectual property harvard university. Review of intellectual property and theories of justice. She also says that such forms are also in consonance with the international legal framework. Intellectual property refers to intellectual creativity of a creator.
Reference to lockes two treatises of government is almost obligatory in essays on the constitutional aspects of property. The book considers the theoretical foundations of intellectualproperty claims are these rights rooted in lockean claims. Theories of justice top results of your surfing theories of justice start download portable document format pdf and ebooks electronic books free online rating news 20162017 is books that can provide inspiration, insight, knowledge to the reader. Utilitarian theories of intellectual property developed and evolved in a symbiotic. Pdf download ethics and law of intellectual property. Also, through significant and important efforts of us negotiators and rights holders all over the globe, we now live in an era in which the benefits of intellectual property rights are recognized throughout the world and the protection of such rights, once the intellectual property is created in any one country or region, is often made global. A just society awards exclusive property rights to creators, and also limits and structures those rights in a way consistent with overall distributive justice concerns. Robert nozicks entitlement theory of justice, libertarian. We should adopt an instrumentalist approach to intellectual property and reject a proprietarian approach an approach which emphasises the connection between labour and property rights. The authors shown below used federal funds provided by. The term intellectual property reflects the idea that this subject matter is the product of the mind or the intellect, and that intellectual property rights may be protected at law in the same way as any other form of property.
He writes on intellectual property as well as legal and market theory. In this introduction to a symposium on intellectual property and social justice, we argue that this view is too narrow. Intellectual property and theories of justice, gosserie a. Online intellectual property and theories of justice ebook pdf download.
This chapter for the oxford handbook on legal studies provides an overview of the theoretical literature in intellectual property, and suggests directions for further study. Both intellectual property and competition law pursue the aim of enhancing economic welfare and innovation, but their direct objectives seem to be in conflict. For locke, property was a foundation for an elaborate vision that opposed an absolute and irresponsible monarchy. Intellectual property law evaluation law and economics analysis law and economics jurisprudence. Intellectual property has increasingly assumed a vital role with the rapid pace of technological, scientific and medical innovation that we are witnessing today. Robert nozick in his famous book anarchy, state and utopia 1974 responded to, in part, john rawls distribution theory as articulated in the latters celebrated book a theory of justice 1971 with the formers entitlement theory.
A preliminary survey most of the recent theoretical writing consists of struggles among and within four approaches. Ip protection of tkgr as an idea of justice and fairness. This paper aims to identify what kind of opportunities we have in incorporating intellectual property ip elements in management theories, as well as in policy issues. Different jurisprudential approaches in ip law making. The seminar covers various theories and philosophical perspectives on intellectual property. Intellectual property refers to creations of the mind. A variety of societal goals must inform intellectual property law because 1 understanding intellectual propertys impact on a variety of social values helps us restrain maximalist intellectual property demands. However, it does highlight and explain the justificatory theories for property that may be applied to intellectual property, while taking cognisance of the limitations of the theories in view of the purpose of the constitution, and particularly section 25 the property clause. Theories of human rights in intellectual property law. See in detail modes of acquisition of property iv theories of property jurists have differed in their views regarding the origin of the property. Hence, and after summarising a possible approach to social justice. Property rights, according to nozick, constrain the extent to which we are entitled to act on our intuitions and theories about distributive justice. The following are theories of property 1 natural law theory. A fundamental critique of the lawandeconomics analysis of intellectual property rights.
Shubha ghosh is currently professor of law at the university of wis consin law school having been professor of law at suny, buffalo, law school for six years. Intellectual property and theories of justice gosseries, et al. Occupation and civil law as efficient bases of property, labor as the efficient cause of the domain of property, sychological exposition of the idea of justice and in justice, and a determination of the principle of government and of right. Moreover, changes in the global economic environment have influenced the development of business models where intellectual property is a central element establishing value and. The intersection between competition law and intellectual property has been a contentious issue since the very beginnings of european communities ec competition law. A fundamental critique of the lawandeconomics analysis. He holds a phd in economics from the university of michigan and a jd from stanford. A philosophy of intellectual property argues that lying at the heart of intellectual property are dutybearing privileges. The only thing that permits us to acquiesce in an erroneous theory is the lack ofa better one.
Intellectual property is divided into two categories. It is true that temporal limitation is applicable to intellectual property. Intellectual property rights like property rights have been protected. These theories represent a more traditional justification of intellectual property, which may be of diminishing relevance to presentday circumstances. Consequentialist theories, however, may be able to separate the institutional and distributive issues in this way, and some theories of liberty may be able to do this also though the distribution. What is property an inquiry into the principle of right and of government. Pdf intellectual property and theories of justice free. This agreement, interalia, contains an agreement on trade related. This theory may be justifiable for corporeal ownership in which its existence may be for indefinite period of time. Particularly, the aim is assessing the impact of the former on the shaping of the latter.
Divided into three parts, this edited volume gives an overview of current topics in law and ethics in relation to intellectual property. Review of intellectual property and theories of justice, co edited by axel gosseries, alain. Intellectual property and theories of justice edited by axel gosseries, alain. The book covers the diversity of relevant theories of justice lockean, rawlsian, etc. Property and ownership stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The most wellknown types are s, patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. How can incentives be taken into account by theories of justice. Intellectual property and theories of justice philo wiki. This publication is the fourth edition of the prosecuting intellectual property crimes manual and provides significant updates to the comprehensive 2006 edition. This insures optimal utilization of the information but of course provides no incentive for investment in research. The law of protects various original forms of expression, including novels, movies, musical compositions, and computer software programs. We will critically examine different theoretical frameworks for describing and justifying intellectual property rights including economic analysis, natural rights arguments, democratic theories and. Menell, property, intellectual property, and social justice. Nw3c researchers examined theories of intellectual property rights ipr, current issues and concerns related to ip, and legal cases through a.
Theories of distributive justice seek to distribute societys resources on the. The term intellectual property refers to a loose cluster of legal doctrines that regulate the uses of different sorts of ideas and insignia. Intellectual property and social justice ana ramalho abstract the main goal of this chapter is to explore the relation between intellectual property and social justice. It examines in depth all areas of prosecuting intellectual property crimes and incorporates a number of recent changes to the case law, statutes, and sentencing guidelines. Ebook theories of justice as pdf download portable.
It addresses practical issues encountered in everyday situations in politics, research and innovation, as well as some of the underlying theoretical concepts. Although history is littered with theories on property, there have been only sparse discussions on intellectual property. Industrial propertyincludes patents for inventions, trademarks, industrial designs and geographical indications. Together, justice, incentives and natural rights are the cornerstones of the justifications of intellectual property. Intellectual property is most of the time limited in time as to the protection accorded by law. This article discusses those theories, evaluates them, and considers the roles they do and ought to play in lawmaking. What differentiates intellectual from real property. This can be seen in the english intellectual property law and the law of passing off ones goodswritingcreation as anothers is a prime example of the strict approach taking in favour of protecting an individuals intellectual property. The theories of intellectual property philosophy essay. In intellectual property, however, after lapse of a certain time the work will be part of the public domain. Intellectual property law examines emerging intellectual property ip issues through the bifocal lens of both economic analysis and individual or social justice theories. Intellectual property ip is a category of property that includes intangible creations of the human intellect. Intellectual property and theories of justice mobipocket. Intellectual property and management theories ellie okada, ph.
1022 914 9 1015 756 1457 605 299 1653 1096 71 1478 853 1413 1117 310 1274 1165 1467 946 567 485 1377 817 427 784 901 827 565 187 156 855 8 1381 221 1175 859 1210 218